Colts fans who watched Spencer Shrader beat Houston with a 53-yarder in September shouldn’t expect much national support for a sweep. The Indianapolis Colts head to Houston on Thursday night at 3-7, and most of the experts, from Sports Illustrated’s MMQB staff to CBS Sports’ Pete Prisco, see the Texans getting C.J. Stroud back on track.
Indianapolis will also be without both starting tackles against Will Anderson Jr., and that has shaped a lot of these picks. Here’s where the experts landed.
Sports Illustrated

Ken Blaze-Imagn Images
The MMQB staff went eight for eight on Houston. Albert Breer, Conor Orr, Matt Verderame and the rest of the panel all picked the Texans straight up, which says a lot about how far the Colts have fallen since the deadline trades.
Line up the two quarterbacks next to each other, and the vote makes sense. Stroud has thrown 19 touchdown passes and three interceptions with a 102.4 passer rating, while Daniel Jones has seven touchdown passes and 12 interceptions. That nine-interception gap is the clearest difference between two 3-win teams.
CBS Sports

Scott Galvin-Imagn Images
Pete Prisco also took Houston, but he expects a much closer game than the rest of the field. He predicted a 30-27 Texans win, pointing to the Colts’ win over Miami and a Houston defense that has struggled. “Look for the Colts to hang around here, but the Texans will win it,” Prisco wrote.
His colleague Tyler Sullivan sees a different game. Sullivan projected a 30-17 Houston win, a 13-point margin that looks more like the 42-7 loss in Jacksonville than the September meeting.
ESPN

ESPN’s Football Power Index is the most generous to Indianapolis. FPI makes the Texans 6.6-point favorites with a 74% chance to win, according to ESPN’s Week 11 projections, which still points to a one-score game.
That fits how the first meeting played out. Houston managed only 223 total yards in Indianapolis, and the Colts’ path is the same formula: Jonathan Taylor, field position and a kicker who is 9 of 10 from 50 yards and beyond. The Texans lost Azeez Al-Shaair to injured reserve, and Danielle Hunter is out again, so Houston’s defense will be missing two key starters on Thursday.
Closer to home, Doug Farrar was the only one of our four staff pickers to take the Colts with the points in our Week 11 picks, while Cory Bonini, Luke Easterling and Craig Ellenport sided with Houston. None of the picks here has Indianapolis winning outright, which is about where a team that sold off at the deadline should expect to be.
More on the Indianapolis Colts
- Colts at Texans Analytics Report Week 11: Jonathan Taylor’s Run Game Is Indy’s Best Edge
- Here’s What Should Scare the Indianapolis Colts About Nico Collins’ Houston Texans
- Thursday Night Football: Texans Face Colts as 12.5-point Favorites Despite Losing Four Straight at Home
- Daniel Jones vs. Texans Week 11: 3 Expectations for Colts QB Facing Will Anderson Jr.
