‘Madden’ movie review: What Amazon got right and wrong about John Madden

'Madden' is one maddening movie when it comes to fiction vs. fact, but it's still worth a watch for fans of the beloved late coach and broadcaster.

by Sporting News
‘Madden’ movie review: What Amazon got right and wrong about John Madden

'Madden' is one maddening movie when it comes to fiction vs. fact, but it's still worth a watch for fans of the beloved late coach and broadcaster.

Amazon MGM Studios

How would one describe the new "Madden" movie, which explores the professional life story of NFL Hall of Fame coach and broadcaster John Madden? In a word, maddening. Acclaimed director David O. Russell's latest film is a total American hustle, but it has a few silver linings.

Like most sports biopics, "Madden" isn't a linear, fully accurate retelling of real-life events. Russell, however, dances the line between a tribute to Madden's greatness and an extended caricature of a larger-than-life personality.

Those who want to learn about John Madden will get surface-level insight into what kind of man he was, but they also will be confused about what really happened during his time as Raiders coach, colorful commentator and inspiration for an eponymous video game.

The movie's mixed message has led to a mixed bag of reviews, with critics mostly panning it while audiences have shown it a little love. Here's a look at the best and worst of "Madden," while also separating fiction from fact:

MORE: 'Madden' movie flippantly dishonors John Madden's fun-loving legacy

'Madden' vs. real life: What the movie got right and wrong about NFL legend

Nic Cage and Christian Bale Madden

Chuck Zlotnik / Amazon Content Services

Wrong: Nicolas Cage's accent as John Madden

Madden grew up in the Bay Area. He had a distinct intonation in his legendary voice, especially when using the onomatopoeia he loved to describe NFL action. Cage didn't really try at all to speak Madden and might as well have been Benjamin Franklin Gates from the "National Treasure" movies, this time in a padded bodysuit and trading the map on the Declaration of Independence for a football playbook.

MORE: How John Madden’s first broadcast in ‘Madden’ disrespects NFL broadcaster’s real-life debut

Right: Madden cursing a lot when not on camera

Cage's Madden throws out plenty of f-bombs while coaching the Raiders and when not behind the camera. Although Madden was known for clean speech in the broadcast booth and as a glib pitchman for many products, "Madden curse" took on a whole new meaning with R-rated language.

Wrong: The existence of Raiders superfan neighbor Vince McGary

This character was a fictional composite to help viewers understand the crazy Oakland Raiders fandom in the 1970s. He also existed to include a part for the overrated, unfunny Shane Gillis, who must have the best agent in Hollywood. McGary's presence didn't enhance or advance the story and provided more comedic indigestion than relief. We didn't care enough to see him get married or hang out with Madden like an imaginary friend.

Wrong: Madden's attire in the AFC Championship, Super Bowl 11

Madden was depicted wearing a tight-fitting blue polo in these sideline scenes, taking away from the fact he wore a classic Raiders coaches jacket and made sure to emphasize the "black" in Silver and Black to show his passion for the only NFL team he ever coached.

Right: Christian Bale's accent as Al Davis

Before Jeremy Strong was getting all weird and method, Bale wrote the book on it, embracing every challenge to bury his Welsh-ness and become a specific type of American. Outside of him just yelling too much as The Dark Knight, Bale nails his characters. Al Davis had a weird combination of Brooklyn and Southern twang. Bale swung for the fences with that "swang" and homered.

MORE: How John Madden landed famous video game deal

Wrong: Al Davis'"Just win, baby" speech

The movie has Davis delivering his iconic three-word motto (not to be confused with Commitment to Excellence) to "inspire" the Raiders before they beat the Vikings in Super Bowl 11 on Jan. 9, 1977. In reality, Davis coined "Just win, baby!" seven years later, on Jan. 22, 1984, while accepting the Lombardi Trophy from CBS' Brent Musburger after the Raiders won Super Bowl 18 over Washington, when Tom Flores, not Madden, was their coach and they were representing Los Angeles, not Oakland.

Amazon MGM Studios

Right: John Mulaney playing Trip Hawkins

Mulaney's comedy and delivery don't connect with some people. But he's a much better and necessary addition to the cast than Gills as the eccentric EA Sports visionary Hawkins. He has some great moments with Cage in giving us a quick send-up of how the Madden video game franchise was conceived.

Wrong: Madden's meetings with Trip Hawkins

Hawkins didn't first meet Madden at a party celebrating the Super Bowl 11 victory. He also didn't meet with Madden to explain the video game concept in the "Madden Cruiser" circa 1979. Instead, as is rather well-documented, Hawkins and Madden hammered out the game details, along with producer Joe Ybarra, on an Amtrak train ride from Denver to Oakland between Dec. 16-18, 1984.

MORE: Meet the full cast of the 'Madden' movie

Right: Davis constantly calling to complain to the NFL

Davis is depicted whining about the rival Broncos getting favorable treatment in their win over the Raiders in the 1977 AFC Championship Game. He was known for frequently engaging in controversial communications with NFL commissioners Pete Rozelle and Paul Tagliabue on issues ranging from game results to the franchise's relocation to Los Angeles.

Right: Davis getting upset about Madden wanting to retire from coaching

Davis was disappointed, but understood why his friend wanted to step down. Madden wanted to focus on his health and his family, given his concerns about an ulcer and burnout. There was, however, no real begging and pleading from Davis to convince Madden to stay past the 1978 NFL season.

Right: Madden being the first to visit Derek Stingley Jr. in the hospital

Madden was shaken by the 1978 preseason game incident when Raiders defensive back Jack Tatum delivered a shoulder-to-helmet hit on Patriots wide receiver Darryl Stingley. Stingley suffered multiple broken vertebrae and a compressed spinal cord, leading to lifelong tetraplegia.

Madden and many Raiders players showed immediate compassion for Stingley. Madden was the lone hospital visitor for Stingley after the Patriots had planned to leave their own player behind in Oakland. Madden made the phone call that got Patriots officials to stop the team plane just as it was about to take off. Only then did they return and understand the severity of Stingley's injury.

Right and wrong: Madden's 62-year marriage with wife Virginia

Based on most real-life accounts and for much of the movie, John and Virginia have a loving, very supportive relationship. Although they often led separate lives, with Madden either coaching the Raiders on the road for television duty, there was no danger of them ever divorcing, as the movie suggests a couple of times.

Christian Bale

Chuck Zlotnik / Amazon Content Services

Right: Carol Davis' bouffant perm hairstyle

Although Al Davis' wife adopted her signature look later in her life as "the first lady of Raiders nation", you can't blame Russell for not wanting Sienna Miller to sport the 'do throughout the movie.

MORE: John Madden's 10 best quotes

Wrong: Raiders' John Matusak brandishing a gun in the locker room

Matusak played defensive end late in his NFL career as part of the Raiders from 1976-1982. Along with his noted struggles with drugs and alcohol, he fought through mental health issues before dying at the age of 38 in 1989.

There was an unnecessary scene where Davis is alerted to "John" waving a gun around his teammates. In a league that has had some scary gun violence incidents in team facilities, it doesn't sit well.

Right: Madden did initially pair with Bob Costas at CBS

When Madden wanted to make the transition from coaching to broadcasting, he asked to audition through a mock broadcast to show what he could do. He worked alongside Costas during a Rams-49ers game that Vin Scully was actually announcing live on the network.

Madden felt "terrified" at the time and thought he had blown it by being himself in what's now his signature, often copycatted style. Because Costas endorsed his originality, Madden was ensured to get the job.

Wrong: Madden had several broadcast partners before Pat Summerall

Madden didn't join Summerall full-time right away when he was at CBS in 1979. Costas and Scully were among Madden's early partners in live games. Dick Stockton and Gary Bender were also notably paired with Madden. When Madden proved his worth and was ready to elevate to the "A" team, he was attached to Summerall for the long haul for two reasons.

First, the network had seen the team of Summerall and previous partner Tom Brookshier start to fall flat on NFL games. Second, Madden's style meshed better with Summerall than with Scully, a natural storyteller. Although Summerall was disappointed by the breakup with Brookshier, he soon professionally embraced Madden, who, in turn, made him a better announcer.

Amazon MGM Studios

Wrong: Madden didn't like to fly because of the Cal Poly football team crash

In the movie, Kathryn Hahn, as Virginia Madden, explains that John's fear of flying and his choice to avoid it after his coaching career stemmed from what happened at his alma mater, California Polytechnic State, two years after he finished playing college football for the Mustangs. The team's plane crashed in Toledo, Ohio, after a road trip to Bowling Green, killing 22 of the 48 people aboard, including 16 players and both pilots.

That was a horrible tragedy, for sure, but the real reason cited for Madden preferring to travel by bus or train was his intense claustrophobia.

Right: Carol Davis suffered a heart attack and stroke and went into a coma

Al Davis' wife's near-death condition is used in the movie as a vehicle to show how John and Virginia strengthened their own marital bond. In 1979, Carol had to go on a ventilator for more than three weeks (23 days) after a major cardiac arrest and a stroke. With Al Davis by her side the whole way, Carol woke up and recovered after months of rehabilitation. She would go on to live almost 46 years longer, dying at the age of 93 in 2025.

Wrong: Al Davis never tried to get Madden back to coach in Los Angeles

The Raiders won two rings with Madden's successor, Flores. The first came in Super Bowl 15 against the Eagles after the 1980 season. The second happened a year after the move to Los Angeles, in Super Bowl 18. The Raiders were still thriving under Davis' ownership until 1987, when they dropped to 5-10. Even then, at no point did Davis approach Madden about returning to coach the team in L.A. after a long layoff.

Wrong: There was no "Madden Cruiser" until 1987, only trains

It was nice to see the beloved bus that would take Madden across the country in its earliest form, but the movie makes it feel like it happened not long after he started his broadcasting career, in the late '70s and early '80s. Although it was good to give Madden's longtime bus driver, Willie Yarbrough, some on-screen love, the "cruiser" concept didn't happen until 1987. Before then, Madden traveled by train to and from games, including the legendary 1984 meeting with Hawkins.

Right: Marshawn Lynch and Julian Edelman playing EA game programmers

When it comes to football legends from Oakland, it's arguable that "Beast Mode" is right up there with any former Raider, given how much Lynch has given back to the home community he proudly represents. Also, given how Marshawn doesn't get enough credit for his great intelligence, in football and beyond, it was fun to throw back to his youthful nerd-dom. Although Edelman looks a little like that guy from the Energizer commercial with his He-Man-with-glasses look, he also was a worthy co-cameo.

Right: Snoop Dogg in the Madden gaming montage

If you could pick one person to play themselves playing the Madden video game in the movie, would it really be anyone else? Fo' shizzle, that felt right on the mizzle.TgQPHd|||[]

TgQPHd|||[]

Wrong: Shane Gillis getting too much extra screen time

Casting Gillis might have seemed clever at some point (we have no idea why), but not just a few weeks after his latest disastrous "Saturday Night Live" appearance. Mulaney, being the actually good former "SNL" writer, meanwhile, crushed his sixth time hosting the week of the movie's release. Gillis is also unnecessary and unfunny with Peyton Manning or Post Malone in the "Bud Light" commercials.

The most offensive thing Gillis has done is somehow being allowed to appear with the Academy Award-winning Cage and the Academy Award-winning Bale. Just wait a little while longer, and he'll go the way of Dane Cook.

Right: Madden and Al Davis remained best friends until the end

Let's end on a positive note. The best thing about the movie — aside from adding unnecessary, made-up tension between Madden and Davis — is that it clarifies how much love and respect the two had for each other, even if they didn't get to win more championships together. Cage's casting might be questionable, but it's often saved by the scenes with Bale. Like the tears Al Davis shed when John Madden presented him at the Pro Football Hall of Fame, that comes with all the feels.

Published:
by Sporting News

Related News

Read All

    You May Also Like

    Shop All
    Philadelphia Eagles Mitchell & Ness Head Coach Hoodie
    Regular price
    $119.99
    Sale price
    $119.99
    Regular price

    Philadelphia Eagles Mitchell & Ness Head Coach Hoodie

    1 Last Item
    Cooper DeJean Philadelphia Splatter
    Regular price
    $28.99 - $33.99
    Sale price
    $28.99 - $33.99
    Regular price

    Cooper DeJean Philadelphia Splatter

    Forever EAGLES not just when are winning Philadelphia Football Sweatshirt, Philly T-shirt, Trending Eagles Fan Shirts, Football Crewneck, Eagles Hoodie, Superbowl GIfts
    Regular price
    $15.99 - $39.99
    Sale price
    $15.99 - $39.99
    Regular price
    $26.99

    Forever EAGLES not just when are winning Philadelphia Football Sweatshirt, Philly T-shirt, Trending Eagles Fan Shirts, Football Crewneck, Eagles Hoodie, Superbowl GIfts

    10 Last Items
    Super Bowl Philadelphia Football Eagles Super Bowl Champs Trending Eagles Fan Shirts, FLy Eagles Fly, Eagles Hoodie, Superbowl Gifts
    Regular price
    $15.99 - $39.99
    Sale price
    $15.99 - $39.99
    Regular price
    $26.99

    Super Bowl Philadelphia Football Eagles Super Bowl Champs Trending Eagles Fan Shirts, FLy Eagles Fly, Eagles Hoodie, Superbowl Gifts

    10 Last Items
    Super Bowl Philadelphia Football Eagles Super Bowl Champs Trending Eagles Fan Shirts, FLy Eagles Fly, Eagles Hoodie, Superbowl Gifts
    Regular price
    $15.99 - $39.99
    Sale price
    $15.99 - $39.99
    Regular price
    $26.99

    Super Bowl Philadelphia Football Eagles Super Bowl Champs Trending Eagles Fan Shirts, FLy Eagles Fly, Eagles Hoodie, Superbowl Gifts

    10 Last Items
    Philadelphia Eagles Mitchell & Ness Legendary Slub Long-Sleeve T-Shirt
    Choose Title
    Regular price
    $59.99
    Sale price
    $59.99
    Regular price

    Philadelphia Eagles Mitchell & Ness Legendary Slub Long-Sleeve T-Shirt

    2 Last Items