"Madden" is being roasted like a Thanksgiving turducken.
The Prime Video movie, which was released this week, was supposed to be a biopic about the Super Bowl-winning coach, one-of-a-kind broadcaster and video game creator who captured the imagination of multiple generations in a fun-loving light. Instead, it left Madden fans like me pissed off.
How can you do that to John Madden? I watched "Madden" on Wednesday night. I texted back and forth with my buddy J.D. — my high school QB and Madden-loving friend who was every bit as angry.
Understand how much '90s kids like us loved Madden. We heard the legends of "The Raider Way" from our dads about those Madden-coached Oakland teams of the 1970s. Given the choice, I can recite "The Autumn Wind" before any of Shakespeare's sonnets in high school.
MORE: How John Madden’s first broadcast in ‘Madden’ disrespects NFL broadcaster’s real-life debut
We loved the tag-team with Pat Summerall in the booth — the way Summerall's deadpan play-by-play meshed with Madden's off-the-wall commentary that could literally go anywhere. We loved the Gatorade family tree. We loved the telestrator. We loved the way he said "Brett Favre!" It's the best announcing team ever.
J.D. and I once created a team in college on "Madden 2002" made exclusively of Big Ten players with a backfield of Eddie George and Mike Alstott. We ran the ball a lot. The video game was a guaranteed every-year purchase growing up.
That was just it. John Madden captured football fans' imaginations like no other person before — and in a space increasingly devoid of creative thought, we were given that movie the week before the NFL on Thanksgiving?
What an insult. Not to us. To John Madden.
MORE: How John Madden landed famous video game deal
Why 'Madden' disrespects legendary broadcaster
To be fair, Nicolas Cage was up against an impossible task. Love Cage, but he had no chance in taking on the role of Madden. Who could?
This movie should have been fun, because that was the Madden experience. Consider that Sporting News ranked the top 32 football movies of all time ahead of the release. We went deep into the playbook.
Madden made cameos in "Little Giants" and "The Replacements" — and those are without question two of the most fun football movies of all time.
This wasn't a fun watch. What was the goal here? To show the relationship with Raiders owner Al Davis, and the highlight of the movie is Christian Bale's performance in that role? This blows through Madden's three-part act as coach, broadcaster and video game revolutionary at hyper-speed, with nothing to latch on to save a few moments where it showed Madden's humanity.
We wanted to see more of that. Yeah, Madden would be the guy who stays in the hospital with New England receiver Darryl Stingley. Madden would be the guy who would help his successor Tom Flores. Madden would be the guy at the bar downing a Miller Lite, telling you about a perfect play to beat a Cover 4 defense.
MORE: Meet the full cast of the 'Madden' movie
Madden was the larger-than-life, hard-working guy, and that is why every '90s kid who put on a pair of shoulder pads at any level loved him. Worshipped him even. He was the football genius who never, ever talked down to his audience.
So why make a movie that critics have spent two days preloading potshots waiting for, a movie they knew was busted coverage?
You could make the argument that Madden was a fun-loving goof who could care less about the critics and appreciate the tone of the film, which does feature a series of fun cameos from Marshawn Lynch, Snoop Dogg and Chris Long — who pops in as his father, Howie. That was a nice touch.
But this is supposed to be a tribute — and it simply does not do right by Madden. Jamie Foxx as Ray Charles. Rami Malek as Freddie Mercury. On the football side, Denzel Washington as Herman T. Boone. Those were all too-real performances where you could feel that presence. Perfect tributes.
I tried hard to love the movie. I give every football movie every benefit of the doubt because I love football. It just could not get there with this.
MORE: The best football puns critics used to pan disastrous 'Madden' film
Will 'Madden' legacy flop or become a cult classic?
You know what the best part of Madden was? When his son says, "Load the wagon" in the first 10 minutes before the AFC championship game against the Steelers. Of course, that's a homage to Madden's famous quote, "Don't worry about the horse being blind, just load the wagon."
That was the essence of Madden. Something that didn't make sense but was somehow perfect. This movie doesn't make sense, and there were way too many glaring imperfections. It gravitated toward anybody but Madden. Shane Gillis as a super-fan? Is Bale the main character? What are we doing?
Go ahead and ask, "What would you have done differently?" Maybe center the movie on one of those three chapters. A 90-minute movie on the '70s Oakland Raiders, his broadcasting career or the video game creation. Given those three choices, I would have liked a movie on those Raiders teams. That's the chapter I wasn't alive for.
Ben Affleck and Matt Damon pulled that off with "Air," the story behind Michael Jordan's relationship with Nike. It's a rewatchable, nostalgic '80s movie. It was fun. I watch it whenever it is on.
That's why movies like this are tricky. We wanted to relive the Madden legend the way we remember it in the 1990s, not text our friends about how much we hated it. Again, it's not about us. It's about Madden.
I don't think it will rise beyond the critics' blistering takes and become a cult classic, like, for example, "Necessary Roughness." That has terrible Rotten Tomatoes scores, too, but we all know about the Texas State Armadillos to this day.
When Madden died in 2021, I wrote: "When an announcer breaks out a telestrator to diagram a play, you'll think about Madden. If a NFL player shows up on next year's cover of "Madden 23," then there will be talk about curses. That's Madden, too. Perhaps nobody made football more fun for everyone."
I hope it stays that way, too, for Madden's sake. It will require forgetting about that movie.
