Eli Manning spent 16 seasons making memories with the New York Giants. Away from the football field, he and his wife, Abby McGrew, were also building a home in Summit, New Jersey. The couple purchased the historic property in 2014 for $4.7 million.
Built in 1904, the Georgian Revival mansion offered plenty of space for the growing family. It sat on 1.1 acres and covered approximately 9,000 square feet.
Manning and McGrew began an extensive restoration after buying the home, bringing its historic character together with modern comforts.
The finished property featured six bedrooms, five full bathrooms and four half-bathrooms. Eight restored fireplaces added to its character.
There was also a home gym, an in-ground swimming pool and a temperature-controlled pool house with an indoor golf simulator.
One of its more unusual features was a subterranean wine cellar with room for 750 bottles. The property also offered extensive outdoor space, giving the family privacy in one of New Jersey’s sought-after communities.

Nathan Ray Seebeck-USA TODAY Sports
Manning’s time in the house coincided with the final years of his playing career. He retired in January 2020 after winning two Super Bowls and spending his entire NFL career with the Giants.
Later that year, the Summit residence went on the market for $5.25 million.
Jersey Digs reported on the listing, which placed the asking price $550,000 above the couple’s original purchase.
That represented an increase of roughly 11.7%, before accounting for restoration costs and other expenses.
The listing offered a glimpse of how the former quarterback had upgraded the historic property during his years in New Jersey. It also marked a change after his retirement, as Manning began a new chapter beyond the Giants.
