A Shootout in Orchard Park Is the Expert Consensus, and Josh Allen Wins It Over Lamar Jackson

Josh Allen and the Bills are the pick for 22 of 23 analysts across four major outlets, with most expecting a high-scoring win over Lamar Jackson's Ravens.

by Athlon Sports
A Shootout in Orchard Park Is the Expert Consensus, and Josh Allen Wins It Over Lamar Jackson

Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen (17)

David Brytus-Imagn Images

Bills Mafia has seen enough Allen-Jackson classics to expect fireworks, and the national experts are preparing for the same thing. Most of them still have the Buffalo Bills winning Sunday at Highmark Stadium, even with Lamar Jackson cleared to start for Baltimore after missing three games with a high ankle sprain.

Across NFL.com, ESPN, CBS Sports and Sports Illustrated, 22 of 23 analysts picked Buffalo. The common thread is points. Eight of the nine projected scores clear the 54.5 total, and almost all of them expect Josh Allen to have the last word.

NFL.com: Bills, five of five

Oct 4, 2026; Baltimore, Maryland, USA; Baltimore Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson (8) sits on the bench after being removed from the game due to a possible injury during the third quarter against the Tennessee Titans at M&T Bank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Tommy Gilligan-Imagn Images

Tommy Gilligan-Imagn Images

Every NFL.com analyst took Buffalo, with Gennaro Filice at 36-29 and Bobby Kownack at 35-31. Brooke Cersosimo’s 26-21 was the only projection with neither team reaching 27.

Kownack leaned on history, from the Allen-Jackson rivalry to the Bills’ long run of wins coming off a bye. He also conceded that Buffalo’s defense is a weakness and that the offense may need to win a shootout, a concern we covered with Jim Leonhard’s defense allowing 29-plus points five times.

ESPN: Bills, two of three

Sep 7, 2025; Orchard Park, New York, USA; Baltimore Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson (8) runs the ball during the fourth quarter against the Buffalo Bills at Highmark Stadium.

Mark Konezny-Imagn Images

Eric Moody (31-27) and Seth Walder (30-27) picked Buffalo in ESPN’s Week 8 guide, and the Football Power Index gives the Bills a 61.4% chance to win. Pamela Maldonado went with Baltimore, 31-28. “Both offenses have ways to keep scoring,” she wrote, expecting Jackson to attack Buffalo through the air.

Walder’s bold prediction is a warning for Allen. He expects Baltimore to intercept him on a play-action pass, citing the Ravens’ top-ranked play-action defense.

CBS Sports: Bills, seven of seven

Oct 12, 2026; Inglewood, California, USA; Buffalo Bills linebacker Greg Rousseau (15) blocks a field goal from Los Angeles Rams place kicker Harrison Mevis (92) during overtime at SoFi Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jayne Kamin-Oncea-Imagn Images

Pete Prisco has it 35-30 Buffalo. “Look for a shootout here with Josh Allen getting the best of it,” he wrote in his Week 8 picks, while questioning how much Jackson’s ankle will limit him. Jared Dubin, Ryan Wilson, John Breech and Dave Richard joined him on the CBS panel, with Tyler Sullivan and Jamey Eisenberg also taking the Bills.

Sports Illustrated: Bills, eight of eight

Oct 18, 2026; Paradise, Nevada, USA; Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen (17) is tackled by Las Vegas Raiders cornerback Hezekiah Masses (35) in the fourth quarter at Allegiant Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Christopher Trim-Imagn Images

The SI staff went 8-0 for Buffalo, though it made its picks with Jackson’s status unsettled. “With Lamar Jackson’s injury status still up in the air, our whole staff has picked Buffalo to win,” the staff wrote. Jackson has since been cleared, which makes this group’s sweep the shakiest of the bunch.

The Bills’ case doesn’t depend on Jackson’s ankle. Buffalo leads the NFL at 32.8 points per game and ranks first in EPA per play, according to our analytics breakdown, while Baltimore blew a 13-0 halftime lead in a 35-13 loss to Cincinnati last week. The pressure falls on a Bills secondary that has to slow Zay Flowers, which is why we called Derrick Henry or Zay Flowers the defense’s biggest dilemma. Our bold predictions for Bills-Ravens start with Greg Rousseau getting to Jackson.

More on the Buffalo Bills

  • How to Watch Ravens vs Bills for Free: NFL Week 8, Live Stream, TV Channel
  • Final Injury Report for Ravens-Bills: Will Lamar Jackson, DJ Moore Play?
  • Should You Start Khalil Shakir Against the Ravens in Week 8? The Slot Matchup Says Yes
  • Baltimore Ravens at Buffalo Bills NFL Prediction, Picks & Odds for Week 8
Published:
by Athlon Sports

Related News

Read All

    You May Also Like

    Shop All
    Josh Allen: We Love You 17
    Regular price
    $30.00 - $66.00
    Sale price
    $30.00 - $66.00
    Regular price

    Josh Allen: We Love You 17

    Josh Allen Buffalo Vintage Head
    Regular price
    $33.99 - $35.99
    Sale price
    $33.99 - $35.99
    Regular price

    Josh Allen Buffalo Vintage Head

    Gabriel Davis: One Hand
    Regular price
    $30.00 - $66.00
    Sale price
    $30.00 - $66.00
    Regular price

    Gabriel Davis: One Hand

    Josh Allen Buffalo Invert
    Regular price
    $34.99 - $38.99
    Sale price
    $34.99 - $38.99
    Regular price

    Josh Allen Buffalo Invert

    Josh Allen Buffalo Invert
    Regular price
    $51.99 - $55.99
    Sale price
    $51.99 - $55.99
    Regular price

    Josh Allen Buffalo Invert

    Josh Allen Buffalo Invert
    Regular price
    $33.99 - $35.99
    Sale price
    $33.99 - $35.99
    Regular price

    Josh Allen Buffalo Invert